Land Survey Dispute

Unfortunately, you'll never prove that it was him who did it. At least you know where your corner is supposed to be.

Inform your surveyor that the monument he found has been removed. He may be able to explain to the neighbor the validity of the found monument and how it is consistent with the subdivision plat.

If that fails, and the neighbor isn't being neighborly, take the survey to your attorney and explain the situation to him/her. A letter notifying the neighbor of the intent to take legal action if he continues to destroy the boundary monument(s) might dissuade him from pulling the next one set by your surveyor.

Being a Mississippi surveyor, I am interested in knowing where this is happening.  Please give us your location.

As others have said above, the fact that the point is now gone, doesn't prove that your neighbor did it.

You probably should hire the surveyor to set the point again, something deep and more permanent, harder to pull, and also install a camera

If you have him on video pulling the corner again that would give you the evidence you'd need to take him to small claims to have him held liable for the cost. He probably won't pay but then you would have a judgement that you could use to put a lien on his property. If he's a total loser though, likely be a while before you collect anything. One fellow I know who had a problem similar installed a steel bollard filled with and set in concrete for his corner. nothing short of a D6 is going to budge that thing.

There are several things to consider:

There is (was) a wire flag nearer to his fence corner than the flagging stretched out of the ground that may mark your corner. That wire flag may mark an additional corner that may or may not also be your corner.

You and your neighbor could have different boundary corners and could both be right or both be wrong.

Are you sure that the flagging coming up out of the ground is tied to your boundary corner location? That is a method of boundary corner marking that I am unfamiliar with. Typically a tall wood stake, wire flag or both is what I am used to doing and seeing, but regional differences could include just a piece of flagging.

Your neighbor could have pulled 'just the flagging' off (since the top was tied to what appears to be his fence) and the actual metal marker is still in the ground below the surface.

Yes, agreed, the best advice is to call your surveyor and ask them to help you understand where you boundary is located.

@oldpacer 

That's a common method in New England, but normally for less urban locations.  Flagging tied at one end to the monument, stretched out and tied to a tree branch, so it can be found in 3 feet of snow

That said, I just set a rebar this morning near a fence, set a tall stake next to it, and also tied some flagging to the nearby fence

I had a neighbor pull a pin I set.  What worked for  my client  was to send a bill to the alleged culprits husband.   Never saw any payment but the pin was never messed with again.

@oldpacer the tied flagging going vertical is a regional thing  I practice in NJ and we don't do that, we do what you do.  In some FB groups that I'm in, it is a popular practice, particularly in FLA.

@chris-bouffard    Must be a South FL thing.

@oldpacer it mostly seems to be.  Looks kind of silly to me.

Did he tell you why the survey was "invalid"?

The results were founded in my favor.

Surveying is a fact finding mission, not a win/lose proposition. The facts turned out to be as you expected.  But favorability has nothing to do with it. 

I'm in South FL and nobody I know makes a habit of tying flagging between irons and other stuff. Seen it sometimes to make irons easier to find when the lathe is gone like if the cows are wiping them out. Or, if there's other junk in the ground nearby like old signs or grounding rods to help the next guy differentiate between what they're beeping/digging up...

Personally, I wouldn't make a big deal about it. Depending on what's at stake perhaps you have to do something, but I wouldn't wanna have a potentially ongoing dispute with a goofy neighbor. Calling the surveyor and asking if they can reset the points since the survey was recently done might not cost too much. At that point the camera idea and proving somebody has disturbed those points would give you some leverage going forward.

Like the guys said above, there's lots of possibilities so I wouldn't jump to conclusions or begin anything adversarial unnecessarily. 

In the woods sometimes we tie flagging to the pipe and up to a tree branch to make the location more visible especially when setting up control. Not in residential neighborhoods though.

In the woods sometimes we tie flagging to the pipe and up to a tree branch to make the location more visible especially when setting up control. Not in residential neighborhoods though.

Years ago we had done a relatively large boundary survey and when the client went out to look at (for) the corners he reported he couldn't find one of the rear corners.  The boss sent me out to reflag it.  It tied more fluorescent pink flagging to the corner and then up about 5 feet to a nearby pine tree.  The client called back in a bit of a huff saying he still couldn't find it.  Back out I went.  I tied one end of a roll of flagging to the pin and rolled all of it out headed toward the road.  When that roll ran out I tied another roll to it and kept going.  Just before the third roll ran out I got to the road and tied the end to a power pole up about 5 feet.  The client called back the next day and apologized, saying he just didn't walk back far enough to find it.  He thanked us for taking the tie to mark it so well.  I hate to use that much flagging but it got the job done.

Andy

I would start by asking your surveyor if they can discuss the results of the survey with your neighbor.  It's not fair that you'll have to pay more money because your neighbor is a jerk, but it may save you money in the long run if it prevents a war or even if it turns into a war.