Notifications
Clear all

Brass or Bronze?

17 Posts
15 Users
0 Reactions
14 Views
allen-wrench
(@allen-wrench)
Posts: 307
Member
Topic starter
 

Is there a surefire way to tell if a cap is brass or bronze? I've always just called everything a brass cap, but it seems that some might actually be bronze. How would you know?

 
Posted : March 31, 2017 9:10 am
jhframe
(@jim-frame)
Posts: 7283
Member
 

There's some overlap between brasses and bronzes, but basically brass is copper and zinc, while bronze is copper and tin. They can be hard to tell apart unless you're machining them.

I'm told that if you swab brass with hydrochloric acid it'll look red like copper due to the surface zinc being swabbed away, but who carries hydrochloric acid with them?

 
Posted : March 31, 2017 9:26 am
(@james-fleming)
Posts: 5691
Member
 

Jim Frame, post: 421262, member: 10 wrote: I'm told that if you swab brass with hydrochloric acid it'll look red like copper due to the surface zinc being swabbed away, but who carries hydrochloric acid with them?

Everyone, but accessing it in public can be socially awkward 😉

[INDENT]The main constituent of gastric acid is hydrochloric acid which is produced by parietal cells(also called oxyntic cells) in the gastric glands in the stomach.
[/INDENT]
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gastric_acid

 
Posted : March 31, 2017 9:56 am
(@acd-surveyor)
Posts: 135
Member
 

Jim Frame, post: 421262, member: 10 wrote: There's some overlap between brasses and bronzes, but basically brass is copper and zinc, while bronze is copper and tin. They can be hard to tell apart unless you're machining them.

I'm told that if you swab brass with hydrochloric acid it'll look red like copper due to the surface zinc being swabbed away, but who carries hydrochloric acid with them?

Seems like I saw something where lemon juice would also work, but probably not as good as hydrochloric.

 
Posted : March 31, 2017 10:00 am
Warren Smith
(@warren-smith)
Posts: 830
Member
 

Heh-heh, just throw up on the cap and swab it!

 
Posted : March 31, 2017 10:00 am

dave-karoly
(@dave-karoly)
Posts: 12001
Member
 

Now now, it may not be a cap, it may be a disk or even a plug. 😉

 
Posted : March 31, 2017 12:27 pm
(@mark-mayer)
Posts: 3364
Member
 

Jim Frame, post: 421262, member: 10 wrote: .... but who carries hydrochloric acid with them?

Geologists. They often carry a small bottle to test for limestone.

 
Posted : March 31, 2017 12:48 pm
a-harris
(@a-harris)
Posts: 8761
Member
 

Brass looks more refined than bronze.
I have two 3/4 inch valves that are approved for 600 psi.
The brass is half the thickness of the bronze.
0.02

 
Posted : March 31, 2017 12:59 pm
(@james-fleming)
Posts: 5691
Member
 

Mark Mayer, post: 421297, member: 424 wrote: Geologists. They often carry a small bottle to test for limestone.

Never trust anyone with a large supply of acid (or a shark tank in their secret underground comand post), most likely they're a Bond villain.

 
Posted : March 31, 2017 1:22 pm
(@larry-scott)
Posts: 1056
Member
 

Fortunately calling a bronze disc a brass cap usually isn't source of confusion.

I think brass is yellower, and bronze could pass for gold. I scratch the disc with a knife. Higher copper redder tone. I think bronze is softer.

 
Posted : March 31, 2017 3:15 pm

(@clearcut)
Posts: 937
Member
 

If I recall the order correctly, bronze is harder than brass and will scratch brass. So either carry a small piece of both and perform the scratch test. Or carry along your handy Rockwell hardness test kit.

 
Posted : March 31, 2017 3:43 pm
paden-cash
(@paden-cash)
Posts: 11088
Supporter
 

Allen Wrench, post: 421259, member: 6172 wrote: Is there a surefire way to tell if a cap is brass or bronze? I've always just called everything a brass cap, but it seems that some might actually be bronze. How would you know?

Twenty years ago, when we got the last shipments of "caps" at the highway department from Bernsten they were bronze, and had been for a while. But brass and bronze are almost indistinguishable because of the number of different types that are manufactured. There is yellow bronze, and red brass. From lugging tote sacks each with 50 monuments I can tell you the slightly lighter weight bronze isn't that much lighter.

This chart might give you some sort of idea as to the gray area between the two:

http://www.metalreference.com/Forms_Copper_Alloy.html

ps -most all of Bernsten's "caps" are bronze.

 
Posted : March 31, 2017 8:42 pm
bill93
(@bill93)
Posts: 9838
Member
(@stephen-johnson)
Posts: 2342
Member
 

Jim Frame, post: 421262, member: 10 wrote: There's some overlap between brasses and bronzes, but basically brass is copper and zinc, while bronze is copper and tin. They can be hard to tell apart unless you're machining them.

I'm told that if you swab brass with hydrochloric acid it'll look red like copper due to the surface zinc being swabbed away, but who carries hydrochloric acid with them?

Everyone does. You just really don't want to access it. It is in your stomach.

 
Posted : April 4, 2017 2:05 pm
FL/GA PLS
(@flga-pls)
Posts: 7403
Member
 

Bronze is more expensive and surveyors are cheap. 😉

 
Posted : April 4, 2017 2:46 pm

 rfc
(@rfc)
Posts: 1901
Member
 

Jim Frame, post: 421262, member: 10 wrote: but who carries hydrochloric acid with them?

Anyone with a car or truck that has a lead-acid battery. Pry the caps off and use a q-tip swab to get some.

 
Posted : April 4, 2017 4:57 pm
bill93
(@bill93)
Posts: 9838
Member
 

Car batt uses sulphuric. Not interchangeable.

 
Posted : April 4, 2017 5:24 pm