Notifications
Clear all

Which answer is correct?

13 Posts
7 Users
0 Reactions
4 Views
(@flga-2-2-2-2-2-2-2-2)
Posts: 7403
Illustrious Member Registered
Topic starter
 

Things that make life fun........  

a2KjM4D 460swp
 
Posted : 27/08/2023 7:18 am
(@bill93)
Posts: 9834
 

That's entirely a matter of convention by definition, but i think the TI one is more commonly used.

 
Posted : 27/08/2023 7:31 am
(@flga-2-2-2-2-2-2-2-2)
Posts: 7403
Illustrious Member Registered
Topic starter
 

@bill93 

From the PEMDAS pounded into me here I go with the Casio. (even though their calculators ain't worth a toot)  

What do the math wizards on here say?

 
Posted : 27/08/2023 7:37 am
(@bill93)
Posts: 9834
 

I think the original standard was to consider M and D equal priority and fall back on left to right in the expression. The mneumonic PEMDAS was a loose expression of that idea, but some have taken it literally, unfortunately.

https://www.mathsisfun.com/operation-order-pemdas.html

 
Posted : 27/08/2023 7:48 am
(@bill93)
Posts: 9834
 

The TI version goes back to Fortran. I think before programming and calculators people just avoided the ambiguity.

 
Posted : 27/08/2023 7:56 am
(@dougie)
Posts: 7889
Illustrious Member Registered
 

GIF
 
Posted : 27/08/2023 8:31 am
(@mathteacher)
Posts: 2081
Noble Member Registered
 

The TI applies the rules as usually understood.

But HP users, how would you enter the problem and what is your answer?

 

 
Posted : 27/08/2023 8:34 am
(@aliquot)
Posts: 2318
Noble Member Registered
 

The lesson here is to understand your calculators notation, amd when writing out mathematical expressions never write them like this. 

As far as the Casio vs. HP debate. HP'S historical have an edge because doing many similar calculations at a time was faster, but not many people do that kind of calculations with a calculator these days. For one off and more complicated calculations (especially dealing with fractions and angles in anything other than radians) the Casio has an edge. It is also much more helpful for those learning math. Of course this edge is easily canceled out by familiarity with the HP.

I still use the Casio I bought in the mid '90's as my primary calculator and teach math and physics with Casios. 

I have an HP-35 but haven't used it for years, because computers and data collectors have taken the place of everything I used it for in the past.

 
Posted : 27/08/2023 9:59 am
(@bill93)
Posts: 9834
 

6 enter 2 divide 1 enter 2 plus multiply

Which yields 9

 
Posted : 27/08/2023 9:59 am
(@aliquot)
Posts: 2318
Noble Member Registered
 

Your Casio is set to "linear input" so it reads 6÷2 as a fraction. The default on Casios is the natural input which will give you the same result at the TI.

20230827 120553

 

 
Posted : 27/08/2023 10:09 am
(@bstrand)
Posts: 2272
Noble Member Registered
 

The correct answer is it's a poorly written equation and you wouldn't see this from anyone who sat through a basic math class since reducing fractions is like... day 1 material.  Throw 3(2+1) out there and there wouldn't even be a discussion.

 

 
Posted : 27/08/2023 11:47 am
(@not-my-real-name)
Posts: 1060
Noble Member Customer
 

  Since there is no operator between the number 2 and the parenthesis the answer is 3(3).

 
Posted : 27/08/2023 11:57 am
(@dougie)
Posts: 7889
Illustrious Member Registered
 

@not-my-real-name 


GIF

 


GIF
 
Posted : 28/08/2023 8:42 am
Share: